I turned 35 two months ago. I like the thirties. Not necessarily everything that happened to me during this decade of my life (although all of it matters), but I like being in that age range. You’re being taken more seriously by people, not least because you can take yourself more seriously now. You have, in fact, some things figured out in life, and you are far more relaxed about the ones you haven’t.
As I settle into my Hamburg life more and more, I find that after the twists and turns of the last few years, part of my life looks surprisingly like the vision I had in my head when I was in my teens. I am furnishing my place with a lot of antiques. There are books in all kinds of places and many times I’m reading several at once. I write and paint. I dress up elegantly and go out with friends sometimes and we have intense conversations about life. I do a lot of different things for work, all of them meaningful in their own way, and all of them have something to do with art (and the arts).
There is one part, though, that my 12-year-old self certainly pictured differently. Without thinking too much about it, I assumed that I was going to be with someone, probably living together, who was partaking in all of this. There was, as there is, seemingly, for many people, no question in my mind that I would be happier in a forever-relationship as I was going to navigate adult life. I never pictured kids but I did picture a life partner. As of right now, I am divorced and haven’t been in a committed relationship for three years.
I love talking about love, and while I’m more careful online, mainly to protect the privacy of the people involved, I always found it fascinating to share experiences with friends and peers. Over the years, I’ve collected a vast compilation of stories from people of all ages and all kinds of backgrounds - happily single, still with their first crush for decades, going through divorce with kids, dating casually, you name it. My own love life being unconventional from the beginning, I was always a non-judgmental listener in these matters, and I was ever ready to humor my friends with another turn of events in my own romantic endeavors. I’ve read lots of books on the subject, many of them poor attempts, some of them worthwhile contributions.
While I still love books and antiques for the same reason I loved them two decades ago, my relationship to, well, relationships has changed profoundly. You might think it’s bitterness. After all, I have seen my own marriage fail and most of my friends are no longer with the person they were with when I met them. But it’s not that. Bitterness is giving up on something that seems too hard to understand or to do, and then resenting someone or something for it. That’s not how I feel. Much rather, the reasons I wanted to be in a relationship have, in part, fallen away or migrated to other parts of life, while some aspects of romance I failed to see when I was younger have become more important over time.
Romantic relationships are one of the most conflated area of life, in my opinion. So much projection. And at the same time, the important conversations about it almost never seem to happen. I recently read ‘Should I Stay Or Should I Go?’, which is a guide book by two German couples’ therapists that aims to help people decide if their relationship is still for them. I became increasingly furious while reading because they never properly addressed the most glaringly obvious question of all: What, in fact, is a relationship? What is it supposed to do? And why do we somehow confound love and relationships so much? People hardly ever stop and ask these questions.
I spent most of my twenties in long-term relationships. At the time, I believed, like most other people, that a committed relationship was the ultimate form of love, but unlike most other people, I also believed that this form was up for debate, so from early on I experimented on it with the people I was with. Monogamy, shared quarters, merging finances - it’s what you do, right? Or maybe not? On a walk with my sister recently, I told her about the relationship of a friend of mine. ‘Oh, they’re not living together’, I interjected, when she assumed they did. ‘But then what kind of a relationship is that?’, she asked suspiciously and I laughed because our experiences were so far apart.
It seems almost trite to say it, but then I still catch people confounding the two, so I will say it. Love and relationships are not the same, and as I’ve found during my experiments and in the stories of many of my friends, a classic relationship is not necessarily the ultimate form of love after all. It is a bargain. Whether it’s a conscious decision or a result of your reactive behavior because your childhood wounds transition into your love life, as they inevitably do - either way, you form a pact with someone in the hopes of getting something specific in return. And a lot of people seem to be at a loss as to what that is, specifically. Many times, when I ask people what they want out of their partner, they blank.
Love is a feeling. Whether mutual or not, it doesn’t need a form necessarily, it just is. But most of the time, we want to act on it in some kind of way, romantically, sexually, so we gravitate towards the forms we know. For many of us, it’s the classic relationship, heavily influenced by the patterns we saw in our parents or caretakers and other early influences. Most people want their partner to be monogamous with them, to be available to them every day or most days and to stay committed to them for the rest of their lives. That, in and of itself, is already a lot. Adding to this, people then often choose to have kids together, which completely transforms the romantic relationship into a caretaking-enterprise. On top of working full-time to sustain the loan.
Our ideas of ‘proper’ romantic relationships are based on strong, sometimes contradicting, often unrealistic principles. Romantic and sexual thoughts that are not directed towards the significant other are generally shunned, just like affairs are seen as proof that the love wasn’t strong enough on one side or one of the partners is inherently a bad person. On the one hand, we want partners with whom we don’t have to make an effort, on the other hand, we resent them if they don’t. A lot of people complain about their sex life - and just as many people are unable to have even the most basic conversation about it.
The consequence for me was that whenever I met someone, I treated the situation as if there was no given form of being together, as if we both had to figure this out from scratch. It wasn’t simply a given that I was going to live with someone eventually, for instance. How often we were going to see each other. Which parts of our lives we shared. The form needed to follow what we both wanted and what kinds of people we both were - that, and other circumstances. It is absolutely possible to love someone deeply and to decide, for various reasons, that a relationship is not right. This is not failure. And you can continue to love the person even if you’re not together.
Increasingly, in the last few years, I’ve been thinking about the bargain as a whole. When you have kids, a classic relationship will, in theory, ensure that you’re able to build a family structure that provides safety and stability for the children. Two people, no other parties involved, shared finances, shared house, married forever. You get a partner in crime for this massive project, and you trade in - well, that becomes obvious in any kind of survey about long-term relationship satisfaction.
In other words: If you don’t happen to live that exact model (and even then), it makes sense to ask yourself what you actually want and what you’re willing to trade for it. And I realized that for a long time and because relationships are considered so important in life, I hadn’t seen how I was trading the reassuring ‘availability’ of a partner for my own authenticity. It was more important to me to find and keep someone in my life who loved me enough than it was to protect my own preferences of how I wanted to live and who I wanted to be - who I already was.
Contrary to some other people I know, I didn’t see my divorce as a personal failure, and I don’t encourage that view, because marriage is a contract before the law, nothing more, nothing less. Sorry for upending your world view. (And please, please get a prenup). But even if you look at the romantic relationship itself, failure is a concept for processes in controlled environments where you have all the power and where ‘success’ is defined as a specific end result. But in relationships, the process itself is what matters. Not if you stayed together for ten more years. I had tried to make it work, I couldn’t have done any more. There is no shame in that.
I was, however, obviously very sad to lose my long-term partner. The person you call every night. The person whose little jests and habits are so familiar to you. A form of belonging that’s then violently taken away again, even if you’re the person who’s leaving. In the aftermath of that, the main reason for not entering a relationship again is exactly this, the fear of losing that again. It takes a lot to build a life with someone.
After some time, the grief changes. You realize that you would in fact be able to take that risk again - but would you do it under the same circumstances? I understood that the end of the bargain also meant that I was getting some things back that I had traded in before. Things that I had, in fact, missed dearly. Being on my own time. Not having my mood attached to someone else’s so tightly. Spending more time on my own projects.
As I was talking to people about my divorce, I realized how many adults of all ages are terrified of living alone. And while I had not been living with my husband, not even while we were married, we were obviously spending a lot of time together, and when I met him, I had just come out of a relationship where I had lived with my partner for several years, so it took me longer than I expected to fully enjoy life on my own, especially in the evenings. But now that I do, now that it’s not frightening anymore to be alone that much, I no longer want to trade it in. So the bargains you’re willing to make in the future, they change as well.
There’s another aspect to it too. Whether you’re entering your bargain consciously or simply out of habit, it will come with expectations, and it alters the baseline. Upon meeting someone and discovering your feelings for them, everything you share is a plus, because the baseline was that this person wasn’t in your life to begin with. However, once you enter the relationship state of things, the same things suddenly become a given, and failure to meet those demands - the appropriate amount of messaging throughout the day, the right amount of sexual attention, running a list of shared errands in time - results in a minus, whereas simply delivering on them to each other’s satisfaction is zero, not worth noting after a while. It is very hard to keep up romantic excitement in such an environment long-term.
I’m not anti relationships now and I don’t hate on people who enter them. (I’m not really known for hating on anyone, I think.) But I think if you’re making yourself aware of the types of bargains you enter and the things you truly want out of your time with someone else, these things often don’t match up, and while I often hate on (ha!) statistics, there’s overwhelming evidence that the result is unhappiness, break-up, divorce. In order to build maximum emotional ‘safety’ by binding someone else to us for life, we also often lose track of who the person is outside of the relationship. We see the role and not the person, and we forget that outside of being a partner, they, too, are a complete human being with aspirations that might not match up with our own all the time. I often found that I had a much better relation(ship) with someone some time after the break-up because expectations and reductions didn’t get in the way any more.
So what’s the solution? Forfeiting all thoughts of love? Obviously not. I think it’s important to let the form be dictated by both circumstances and preferences, and to enter any kind of commitment with the readiness to discuss even the most subtle seemingly ‘given’ aspect of it. We don’t have to overthink it, that’s not what I mean. Actually, the opposite. We have to see what’s there, what we want, and not be blinded by preconceived notions we are carrying around from a time where most relationships, happy or unhappy, resulted in life-long marriage and kids and building a house. Some still do. Others don’t. Either way, choose your own adventure. And let me reassure you that living without a relationship is not living without love - and while I pictured my life differently when I was younger, I can safely say that my life satisfaction doesn’t depend on it anymore.
This blog is - and will be - free from disruptive flashy ads. If you’re interested and you want to support my work, you can donate through PayPal or try out the app I used during my recovery, Curable. I’ve also been using a modular backpack you might like for many years. All affiliate recommendations are for products or services I have extensively used myself.